Susanne Komfort-Hein & Johannes von Moltke | Auerbach Lecture 16.11.2026
Manufacturing Distrust
Higher Education in the Culture Wars - a Transatlantic Perspective
Abstract
Whether in AfD party platforms or Project 2025, in the erosion of academic freedom or the planned dismantling of the U.S. Department of Education: the attack on education and knowledge is one of the central battlegrounds of the ongoing shift to the right on both sides of the Atlantic, within the framework of "culture wars" and Kulturkampf. Trump and the MAGA movement in the United States, like the AfD and the New Right in Germany, strategically stoke active distrust of universities and science with the catchphrase of a "loss of trust." The loudly propagated claim is that established educational institutions and concepts have been politically hijacked by a "woke" lobby, and that the social sciences and humanities have been ideologically infiltrated. Objectivity, truth, and value-neutrality, it is alleged, have been sacrificed to a leftist social agenda, as a result of which science has forfeited the trust of citizens and politicians.
We examine the sources from which this distrust is fed and how it is strategically mobilized. Our attention focuses above all on the rhetoric of "common sense" and the logic of social resentment: both dress themselves in the borrowed garb of critique in order to call critique itself, as a scientific procedure, fundamentally into question. Finally, we address how the narrative of distrust takes hold within the institution of science itself, with a dynamic of normalizing right-wing discourse that is, at times, problematic. This happens through the establishment of networks for academic freedom, through large-scale reports on the state of the humanities and social sciences, and through anticipatory obedience in setting up institutes for "civil dialogue," "viewpoint diversity," or "institutional neutrality." This creates zones of ambiguity in which necessary but misguided self-criticism on the part of science and education policy abets its exploitation and depletion from the right. A transatlantic perspective is intended not only to shed light on similarities and differences, but also to open up perspectives for discussing possible strategies for a robust defense of science, universities, and education against this attack.
–